Thursday, July 30, 2009

You are Confused!

I am increasingly amused, as I read scholarship, how often people portray opposing scholars as "confused." I'm sure the so-called "confused" scholar would say the same thing right back. Calling someone else "confused" does not seem very professional to me. Why can't we just disagree in our interpretations without calling someone else confused?

3 comments:

Ken Schenck said...

But I am confused! I think. No wait, I'm not sure.

Jared said...

It is one thing to admit self-confusion...and I think such an admission should be required among Hebrews scholars (does anyone really understand this document?)...but it is quite another to claim that people who disagree with you are confused--that is simply condescending.

It is actually reading Hebrews scholarship that I am finding the "everyone else is confused but me" statements. But I'm not going to name names.

Liam said...

It's really a euphemism. It really means "Prof. So-and-so is a d**k."